|
Soy are rich in protein,
oil, carbohydrates, vitamins, minerals and fiber. They
have been grown in China for at least 5000 years, mainly
in the northern and north-eastern part of the country.
The soya bean became a staple of the Chinese people
diet and continues to be used in many forms including
soya milk, tofu, soy sauce, bean sprouts, soy oil, soy
flour and so on. They can also be dried to prolong their
nutritional value.
The ideal level of cholesterol
is 180 milligrams or less, per 10 milliliters of blood.
Chances of getting coronary heart disease and stroke
increase with cholesterol level that exceeds this. Since
soy protein can effectively reduce the cholesterol level,
a soy protein diet can help prevent these conditions.
According to Dr. James Anderson, even a 10 to 15% reduction
in blood cholesterol level can result in a 20 to 30%
reduction in the risk of coronary heart disease.
Animal studies suggest
that soy/isoflavones inhibit the development of breast
and prostate tumors. These studies are consistent with
the low rates of breast and prostate cancer in Asian
countries. (Source: Dr. Mark Messina at the Talk on
" Health Benefits of Soya Beans", July 10, 1999, Hong
Kong)
The University of Kentucky
metabolism research team, headed by James Anderson,
M.D. reported in the August 3, 1995 issue of The
New England Journal of Medicine that after a
review of 38 clinical studies, it was found that soy
can effectively reduce the cholesterol level. In this
research, an average of 47 gram of animal protein intake
was substituted by soy protein daily. After just one
month, it was found that the cholesterol level had been
reduced by 23 milligrams per 100 milliliters of blood.
This equals approximately 9% of the body's total cholesterol.
For those who had a high cholesterol level at the beginning
of the testing, the reduction was even more significant
at about 20%. The most important finding was that only
the low-density lipoprotein (LDL) cholesterol or "bad
cholesterol", which contributes to atheroclerosis, was
reduced. The high-density lipoprotein (HDL) cholesterol
or "good cholesterol" which protects against heart disease
was unaffected.
Health Benefits of Soybeans
" Presented by Dr.
Mark Messina at the Talk on "The Cow of China", Oct
18, 2003."
Introduction
Over the past decade soyfoods have become increasingly
popular among Westerners because of their purported
health benefits. According to a survey conducted by
the United Soybean Board, in 2003, 28% of Americans
reported using soy products at least once per week,
approximately twice the number who reported using soy
products in 1998.
Expectations are for the spotlight to continue to shine
on soyfoods especially in light of the disappointing
results from the Women's Health Initiative (WHI). In
fact, some experts are now recommending that women between
45 and 70 years of age currently taking hormone replacement
(HRT) discontinue use. Consequently, many women are
seeking alternatives to HRT and many of these women
are trying soy.
Soyfoods provide excellent nutrition,
they are low in saturated fat and without cholesterol
and the quality of soy protein is equal to the quality
of animal protein. Recognition of the high quality of
soy protein led the U.S. Department of Agriculture in
2000 to allow soy protein to replace 100% of the animal
protein in the National School Lunch Program.
Soybeans contain a number of
biologically active components but unquestionable it
is the isoflavones that have received the most attention
and which are most often implicated as the constituents
responsible for the hypothesized health benefits of
soyfoods. Isoflavones are quite different from estrogen
and have a variety of non-hormonal properties that are
especially relevant to cancer prevention and treatment.
Coronary Heart Disease
The cholesterol lowering effects
of soy protein were first demonstrated in humans in
1967. In 1999, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration
(FDA) approved a health claim for soy protein for cholesterol
reduction and in the following year the American Heart
Association endorsed the use of soyfoods for people
with elevated cholesterol. In 2002, the United Kingdom
approved its version of a health claim for soy protein
under the Joint Health Claims Initiative (JHCI).
Soy protein may also be hypotensive
as a recent review found that two-thirds of the better
designed trials reported decreases in blood pressure.
Lowering systolic blood pressure from just 2 - 5 mmHg
has been estimated to reduce stroke and CHD risk by
6-14% and 4-9%, respectively. Furthermore, isoflavones
may have independent coronary benefits. For example,
isoflavones have been shown to increase the flexibility
of the large arteries, and isoflavone-rich soy protein
may enhance arterial reactivity and inhibit LDL-cholesterol
oxidation.
Breast Cancer
Early life factors are thought
to play in the etiology of breast cancer. For example,
breast feeding, parity, and early pregnancy, are thought
to reduce risk of breast cancer. There is an exciting
and intriguing hypothesis that has both animal and epidemiologic
support is that early soy intake is also one of these
early life protective influences.
Consistent with the animal studies
in the United States are the results from two case control
studies, one conducted in Shanghai and the other in
the United States that involved women of Asian ethnicity.
In the former study, soy consumption (11 g soy protein/day)
during the teenage years reduced risk of developing
breast cancer by 50%. Soy consumption during adulthood
had no bearing on these findings. In the latter study,
soy consumption throughout life reduced risk by 35%
whereas soy consumption only during adulthood was not
protective.
Initial interest in the role that soy might have in
reducing breast cancer risk was based on three early
observations: (1) low breast cancer rates in Asia; (2)
animal research showing adding soybeans to the diets
of rats inhibited mammary cancer; and (3) data showing
that weak estrogen-like compounds such as isoflavones
can exert antiestrogenic effects under some experimental
conditions. It is also widely recognized that isoflavones
have potentially important non-hormonal effects relevant
to cancer prevention and treatment.
Osteoporosis
The skeletal effects of both
soy protein and the soybean isoflavones are being investigated.
Numerous short-term clinical trials dating back to the
1980s have shown that soy protein decreases urinary
calcium excretion when replacing animal protein. This
advantage of soy protein is quite attractive considering
most women do not meet dietary calcium requirements.
Various studies have also suggested that isoflavones
may inhibit bone loss in much the same way that estrogen
does.
Menopausal symptoms
Messina and Hughes recently
reviewed 19 trials involving over 1700 women that examined
the effects of soyfoods and isoflavone supplements on
menopausal symptoms. Six trials were excluded from their
analysis, two involving breast cancer patients, two
which reported data on severity but not hot flush frequency,
one that was not blinded, and one that did not include
a control group. They found among the remaining 13 trials
that there was a statistically significant relationship
between initial hot flush frequency and treatment efficacy.
More specifically, the correlation indicates that hot
flush frequency will decrease about 5% (above placebo
or control effects) for every additional initial hot
flush/day in women whose initial hot flush frequency
is 35/day.
Thus, soy and isoflavones have
modest beneficial effects but only in women with frequent
hot flushes. In practical terms this means that in theory
a women with eight hot
flushes per day who experienced
a typical placebo response of 25% would experience a
40% improvement by consuming soy or isoflavones; thus,
hot flushes would decrease from eight per day to 4-5
per day.
Cognitive Function
Dementia rates in East Asia
where soyfoods are consumed, are lower than those in
Europe and rates of dementia and AD are reportedly higher
among Japanese men living in Hawaii compared to native
Japanese in Japan. Additionally, maintaining a more
Japanese lifestyle is associated with better cognitive
function among Japanese women living in the West.
Three clinical trials have found
isoflavones enhance some aspects of cognition and memory.
Prostate Cancer
Worldwide, cancer of the prostate
is the fourth most common cancer and sixth most common
cause of cancer death in men. There are striking differences
in prostate cancer rates among regions in the world,
however. Compared to Western rates, prostate cancer
incidence and mortality in China and Japan is extremely
low; in fact, they are as low as the breast cancer rates
in those countries. The low rates in soyfood consuming
countries provided initial motivation for investigating
the impact of soy intake on prostate cancer risk.
In vitro, the main soybean isoflavone
genistein inhibits the growth of testosterone-dependent
and independent prostate cancer cells. It also reduces
the ability of prostate cancer cells to metastasize
independent of cell growth inhibition. In addition,
in a dose-dependent manner genistein decreases the growth
of human-patient benign prostatic hypertrophy tissue
and prostate tumors in histoculture. Although the epidemiologic
literature is limited, studies in Hawaii, California,
and China, have recently found soy intake to be associated
with a reduced risk of prostate cancer.
|